Meltdowns and tantrums might appear similar on the surface, but there are key differences that can help parents and caregivers better manage these situations.
The main difference between a tantrum and a meltdown lies in the underlying cause and control of the behavior. A tantrum is a purposeful behavior, often exhibited by children, with the aim of reaching a specific goal or obtaining something they desire, such as attention or a particular object. It is a choice and can be stopped, especially if the desired outcome is achieved or if the child realizes it is not effective.
On the other hand, a meltdown is an involuntary response to a stimulus or situation that overwhelms the individual. Unlike a tantrum, a meltdown is not a deliberate action aimed at achieving a specific goal. It is a reaction to sensory overload or an inability to cope with a particular situation, leading to a loss of control.
Key Differences
To further understand the differences between tantrums and meltdowns, let’s examine some key characteristics:
- Purpose – A Tantrum is goal-oriented with the aim of seeking a desired outcome while a meltdown is a reaction to sensory overload or overwhelming situations.
- Control – A tantrum can be stopped if the desired outcome is achieved while a meltdown is involuntary and involves loss of control.
- Duration – A tantrum is usually shorter in duration, but a meltdown can be prolonged and may take time to recover from
- Rewards – A tantrum can be influenced and shaped by rewards while a meltdown can’t.
- Emotional State – A tantrum often involves feelings of frustration while a meltdown is due to distress and overload.
Understanding these differences is crucial for parents and caregivers in effectively managing their autistic children and their behaviors. While tantrums can often be shaped and influenced by rewards, meltdowns are primarily a result of sensory overload and require a different approach.
Characteristics of Tantrums
Understanding the characteristics of tantrums can help differentiate them from autism meltdowns. Tantrums are purposeful behaviors exhibited by children when they are trying to get something they desire, such as attention or a specific object.
The child has some control over a tantrum, and it typically stops when the child gets what they want or realizes their behavior is not successful.
Unlike autism meltdowns, tantrums are a choice and are aimed at reaching a goal. Children may throw tantrums when they are frustrated, upset, or unable to express their needs effectively. They use this behavior as a means to communicate their desires or frustrations.
Tantrums can be shaped by rewards and consequences. If a child is rewarded for good behavior or disciplined for bad behavior, the incentive can stop a current tantrum or prevent future ones.
During a tantrum, the child retains some level of control over their behavior. They may be aware that their actions are causing a reaction from others. Tantrums typically have a shorter duration compared to autism meltdowns. Once the child’s goal is met or they realize their behavior is not effective, the tantrum tends to subside. The duration of a tantrum can vary depending on the child and the circumstances surrounding the tantrum.
Characteristics of Meltdowns
Compared to tantrums, meltdowns are often a result of sensory overload, where there is an excessive amount of information for the individual’s brain to process. Autistic individuals may be more sensitive to sensory stimuli, such as noise, sights, smells, or even certain textures.
These overwhelming sensory inputs can quickly become too much to handle, leading to a meltdown.
During a meltdown, the individual may feel bombarded by sensory information, causing feelings of distress, anxiety, and a sense of being overwhelmed. It’s important to note that these reactions are not intentional but rather a response to the brain’s struggle to process and regulate the incoming stimuli.
Another key characteristic of a meltdown is the lack of control experienced by the individual. Unlike tantrums, which are often purposeful and driven by a desire to gain control or attention, meltdowns are an involuntary response to overwhelming sensory and emotional experiences.
During a meltdown, the individual may exhibit behaviors such as crying, screaming, hitting, or even self-injurious actions. These behaviors are not intended to manipulate or deliberately disobey, but rather a result of the individual’s struggle to cope with the overwhelming sensory and emotional input.
How to Manage Tantrums
There are effective strategies that can help parents and caregivers manage tantrums on their autistic children. Here are some effective strategies that they should consider:
Remember, each child is unique, and what works for one may not work for another. It’s important to tailor strategies and communication approaches to the individual needs and preferences of the child with autism. Patience, consistency, and a supportive environment are key elements in managing and navigating through tantrums.
How to Manage Meltdowns
Meanwhile, meltdowns can be overwhelming for both the individual and their caregivers, but with the right techniques, it is possible to de-escalate the situation and ensure the well-being of everyone involved.
During an autistic meltdown, safety concerns are paramount, and the focus should be on ensuring safety as the meltdown will continue until the energy is spent. Individuals with autism may unintentionally hurt themselves or others during meltdowns, so having a safety strategy in place is crucial.
Here are some de-escalation techniques that can help during meltdowns:
- Remain calm – It’s important for caregivers to stay calm and composed during a meltdown. This can help create a sense of stability and security for the individual.
- Provide space – Find a quiet and safe space where the individual can de-escalate. This space should be free from excessive sensory input, such as loud noises or bright lights, that may contribute to the meltdown.
- Reduce stimulation – Minimize sensory input by dimming lights, reducing background noise, and removing any triggers that may have contributed to the meltdown. This can help the individual regain a sense of control.
- Use calming techniques – Deep breathing exercises, gentle touch, or providing a comforting object can help soothe the individual during a meltdown. It’s important to respect personal boundaries and only use calming techniques if they are welcomed by the individual.
- Wait it out – Meltdowns may take some time to subside, and it’s important to allow the individual to go through the process. Trying to rush or interrupt the meltdown can escalate the situation further.
By implementing various strategies and techniques, parents and caregivers can better manage meltdowns in their autistic children. That said, it’s important to remember that each person is unique, and what works for one individual may not work for another.
Patience, understanding, and ongoing communication are key in supporting individuals with autism during meltdowns.
For exceptional ABA Therapy programs in Charlotte, North Carolina, Eagle’s Will provides top-notch ABA therapy tailored to each individual’s needs. Contact us today to discover how our expert services can make a significant difference in your or your child’s journey.
Sources:
https://www.experia.co.uk/blog/7-differences-between-tantrums-and-autism-meltdowns
https://autismtreatmentcenter.org/knowledge-base/the-difference-between-meltdowns-and-tantrums
https://autismawarenesscentre.com/what-is-the-difference-between-a-tantrum-and-an-autistic-meltdown
https://www.autismparentingmagazine.com/learning-meltdown-vs-autism-tantrum